terex
Friday, March 30th, 2007, 4:12 AM
QUOTE (ajs510 @ Friday, March 30th, 2007, 7:11 AM)

...avoid choosing players that will face each other in the first round (for instance, Daniel Briere and let's say Ryan Smyth for the sake of argument) because the one sure thing is that one of them won't see the second round because Buffalo being the #1 seed and the Isles being the #8 seed, only one team will advance...
Daniel Briere
Thomas Vanek
Sidney Crosby
Jaromir Jagr
Joe Thornton
Paul Kariya
Jason Spezza
Dany Heatley
Marian Gaborik
Evgeni Malkin
G - Martin Brodeur
Cup Win - Buffalo
Silly! You picked Brodeur, 2 Pens, and 2 Sens in your list. Two of these teams are definitely facing each other in the first round. Follow your own advice!

I would balance my team more between the conferences. You are also carrying 8 of 11 players from the East, so I'd swap a couple guys from the West in. I would definitely wait until the seeding is done to really hammer out your final picks. For example, if things ended today and the Pens finished as the 2 seed, I would consider choosing a second Pens forward because they would be playing Tampa Bay in the first round. I am very confident that the Pens PP will light up TB's suspect defense/goaltending and advance to the next round. However, if the Pens finish as the 4/5 seed, I would only take Crosby because I would be much less confident that they would advance. I'd still want Crosby because the series would likely go at least six games.
I would take Datsyuk over Malkin. I would take a Western Conference goalie because those games will certainly be lower scoring, but exactly which one would depend on the potential first/second round match ups. The bottom seeds in the West won't be final until the season's end, so this will be tough to pick ahead of time. I'd probably go with Giguere or Luongo, though, choosing whichever team is not facing San Jose. I think Jagr is a good pick if the Rangers end up playing Atlanta in the first round, which they would if the season ended today. I would have to choose between Spezza and Heatley. The Sens have such a history of choking in the playoffs that I can't put faith in them lasting more than two rounds. I would probably go with Spezza, since goals/assists are worth the same, since I like centers. I think taking both Briere and Vanek is fine, especially if you are picking Buffalo to win it all. That pool sheet can be boom or bust, but I'd heavily lean towards boom. I would take Selanne over Gaborik, but that's just because I've been burned for three seasons by Gaborik (FU holdouts and groin injuries). I think the Ducks have a much better chance to make a deep run than Minnesota.
I'm not sure who I would replace Heatley with. It would come down to match ups, I suppose. I wish the NHL would change the seedings for the top 4 teams like the NBA did last year. Of the top five teams in the east, the Southeast division winner is the weakest. That sucks because #1 Buffalo would play #4 Ottawa in round 2, rather than a much worse SE division winner Atlanta team (or, even worse, Tampa Bay). Same deal with #1 and #4 in the west, with Detroit and Nashville potentially facing each other in the second round. Anyhow, what all of that means is this: by the end of round two, you would be guaranteed to have lost at least one of your three teams' players, between Buffalo, Ottawa, and Pittsburgh, and possibly two of the three. I'd have a hard time taking a second forward from Pittsburgh or Ottawa because of this, even though I think both teams will light the lamp a lot as long as they are in the playoffs.
So, my list would look like this:
From the East:
Daniel Briere
Thomas Vanek
Sidney Crosby
Jaromir Jagr
Jason Spezza
Evgeni Malkin (If and only if the Pens finish as the #2 seed. Kid has a history of playing sick in the playoffs.)
From the West:
Pavel Datsyuk
Joe Thornton
Paul Kariya
Teemu Selanne
G - J.S. Giguere / Roberto Luongo
If the Pens don't finish as the #2, I think I'd go with Zetterberg (He's practicing again, so should be back and healthy for the playoffs) or go with a flyer and take someone like Jarome Iginla or Vincent Lecavalier.
Oh, btw... First post!

I've lurked around FCP since mid-2005. Just discovered the hockey forums this week and finally decided to register and post. I am adding to the ranks of Pittsburgh natives and Penguin fans on these boards. We are taking over!
GO PENS!