ShakeZuma
Thursday, April 3rd, 2008, 1:55 AM
QUOTE (Ron_Mexico @ Wednesday, April 2nd, 2008, 11:11 PM)

I disagree. I watched the replays and rewound them myself as well, and in both of those stoppages, the fighters dropped from the initial blow then went limp for a second when on the ground. How many fights can you think of where I fighter came back from something like that? Probably not a lot. Sure, they recovered when the guy was pulled off of them. It's a lot easier to argue with a ref and throw your hands in the air to the crowd with double vision and a light head than it is to dodge a flurry of bombs. They are trying to make this sport mainstream and take it out of the dark ages, and limp, unconscious fighters taking fists to the head won't allow them to do it.
Basically, my long winded, new to MMA opinion, I think they were good stoppages. Very close, but the right thing to do.
You think he had it in the first place?
completely agree. everybody talking about "he could have come back" doesn't understand the whole purpose of a ref stoppage. if a fighter is out, he can't intelligently defend himself, and serious damage (ie deadness) can occur. doesn't matter if after a few seconds he'll be ok. karo was out, and that arm wasn't "defending" anything; it was limply draped across his face. big difference. when your knees buckle and you slump down like that, you're out, plain and simple. the last thing the UFC needs is some guy getting brain damage or killed because a ref let another fighter continue beating on him when he was completely out, and for that reason in these situations the refs HAVE to err on the side of caution. it isn't about what the fighters "want."
QUOTE (Actuary @ Thursday, April 3rd, 2008, 1:20 AM)

CLAY GUIDA VS. SAMY SCHIAVO
ROUND 1 -- A slow start as the fighters access the situation. Guida is patient as Schiavo lets his hands fly and throws quick combinations. Guida waits for an opening and then scores the takedown. Guida then easily takes the mount position. While in the dominant position, Guida delivers short punches and elbows. The barrage continues with big left punches before the ref finally steps in to halt the fight. Clay Guida def. Samy Schiavo via TKO (strikes) -- Round 1, 4:15.
(from mmaJUNKIE.com)
nice. hope this will get him another ppv showing of some sort. love watching that guy fight.
QUOTE (jayboogie @ Thursday, April 3rd, 2008, 2:02 AM)

Pellegrino was dominating Nate the entire fight, he just got very sloppy on that slam and left his head in too deep. I thought he had the fight won when he was pounding on Nate with his arm trapped in the 1st. Regardless, Nate's got a sick triangle and one of the best guards around.
well to be fair, every fight nate has fought in he got dominated until he found his submission. thats just his style: take a beating until you can slip in some sort of submission. seems to be working pretty well now, but its gonna suck when he gets in there with either a serious striker who knocks him the f
uck out, or another submission guy who beats him to the punch. it definitely was entertaining to see him just wait around for the sub and once he got it just relax knowing that his gameplan completely worked.
QUOTE (jayboogie @ Thursday, April 3rd, 2008, 2:02 AM)

I was real pissed that Joe lost as well. He definitely won that 1st Round and I think he just got tired out there, which is why he gave up the takedown without a sprawl even and got his guard passed. That stoppage sucked in my opinion, those were pitter patter shots that Florian was throwing and nothing was really landing. I can see why the fight was stopped, but I still don't agree with it. Joe didn't have a single mark on his face. I also don't get why they restarted the fight on the feet when Joe got the takedown in the 1st and got elbowed in the back of the head. I still can't stand Kenny, because he tried to make it seem like he beat Joe up, but that obviously wasn't the case. I'm also sick of his stupid elbows that he throws to cut fighters rather than hurt them. It was pretty unimpressive for Florian to have mount for a good 2 minutes and do absolutely no damage.
The Karo stoppage was also bad. Karo had his hands up defending himself eventhough he did get rocked hard by that knee. They should have let that continue. I only like the stoppage when the fighter has their hands to the side and head rolled back, that wasn't the case here.
I didn't particularly "like" the florian/lauzon stoppage myself, but it wasn't going anywhere. joe couldn't get out of the mount, he was almost out of energy, and what else was the ref gonna do, stand them up when florian had a dominant position just because he was punching like a bitch? but seriously though, I hope he gets made fun of endlessly for having a mount on a guy for 2 minutes without getting in a single real punch.
also, I think I am REALLY going to enjoy this season of TUF. you've got pretty much the two funniest dudes in UFC couching. should be great. when the fights were going on and rampage and forrest were talking in the background, I swear it was like a mma version of mystery science theater 3000.