timwakefield
Sunday, January 31st, 2010, 4:33 PM
QUOTE (BigDMcGee @ Sunday, January 31st, 2010, 11:04 AM)

I almost forgot why I bumped this thread. I started watching " The Shield" last week, and I find it puzzling.
I had never seen an episode of the shield before last summer, and then over last summer and fall I ended up watching them all. Got hooked. Anyways, more below.
QUOTE
I feel like HBO TV Shows of the late 90's and early 00's, Oz and the Sopranos specifically, caused a sea change in Television, in subject matter, in grittiness, in realiness, in quality. In some cases, that can manifest itself in genius shows like The Wire, Breaking bad, Man Men.. shows that probably couldn't have been made in 92. But in other ways, you get shows like Dexter, Sons of Anarchy and the Shield. It's the same hack TV show writers that were cranking out bad, boring drama's in the 80's and 90's, but now they can be hacks that write about really ****ed up things.
I don't know how far you are in the Shield, but I'll assume you're still on season 1 or maybe 2 (I don't remember if season 1 is a short season). In other words, I won't have any spoilers in here. I WILL however spoil the first episode, so if you (obviously not BigD, but you, the reader) have not seen the pilot, do not read the rest of this paragraph. The pilot is obviously different than most pilots I've seen. For awhile it's just a cop show, variously decent or cheesy throughout. Then our main character straight murders a fellow police officer. You're like, there's no way they're really gonna do this, how could we root for this guy if he kills a cop? And then, in an instant, it's done. For the entire rest of the series I could not get that out of my head for even an episode. Mackey, who has been presented to us as our hero, just made himself into a bad guy, and it's not the type of thing that can ever be redeemed. Literally,
nothing he could ever do could make up for that, or could make me not want to see him go to jail for life. He not only murdered a cop in cold blood, but he murdered an apparently really good, certainly clean cop, and his crew was
fucking in on it with him. I'm not spoiling anything by saying that the whole rest of the series the viewer has to come to terms with this, and constantly has to consider it in relation to every other event. Just in presenting us with a group of supposed protagonists who are truly evil, the show is doing something very interesting. Like the guys on The Sopranos are gangsters or whatever, but Tony sure as shit didn't murder a police officer in the first episode.
QUOTE
And that's not to say that the Shield is all bad. I infact enjoy it, if nothing else because there's at least one moment an episode where I go " holy shit, I can't believe they put that on TV". But at the same time, it's still the same kind of bad melodrama cop show that's been cranked out for decades. THe same bad acting, the same poorly written dialog, the same format, the same sort of one dimensional characters. It's just that all the restrictions on subject matter and content have been tossed aside.
I agree with this for the most part, but like I said I was still hooked for the whole series. I've watched every season of 24 for example (save for season 6), and it annoys me on a minute-by-minute basis most of the time, but I still obviously enjoy watching it. Anyways I'll just say this as an overall critique/recommendation for the show: it
is better than stuff like L&O and NYPD Blue, and not just because it's "grittier." There are interesting (and sometimes less-interesting) storylines which stretch across the whole series. Without spoiling anything at all, there are a couple of highlights late in the series: Forest Whitaker shows up for an entire season, and even though his character is
almost just plain silly in his intensity, at times he's also pretty amazing. Probably the most intense mother
fucker ever on tv (Whitaker's character). I can't even think of another word to describe him. And then the other thing to look forward to is the final season. It's not perfect or anything, but there are some very excellent scenes and episodes.
QUOTE
So, as long as The Shield keeps delivering car wrecks, I'll keep watching. If it veers into self-indulgence and boring subplots a la Dexter I'll jump ship.
There is a Shield thread, but I only read parts of it after I finished the series. Anyways, you should update here if you keep watching it. I haven't ever really discussed it, so I'd probably be interested in your continued thoughts on it.
QUOTE
Maybe it will surprise me and will get better as the seasons go on, but I'm skeptical.
I think you'll actually be pleasantly surprised. Of course there are low points, and sometimes it'll be kind of repetitive or obvious, but they do keep the violence level and the 'holy shit!' level pretty high throughout. Really the main thing that gets silly about the violence is the idea that these same cops (not just Mackey and his boys but the patrolmen who they also show) get into like a shoot-out or high-speed-chase every week. As in, the only problem with the action in the show is that it's unrealistically omnipresent. And just know that the final season was by far the most exciting, despite being a little bit
too much at times, as any action/drama is wont to do in their conclusion.