Is Kurt Warner a Hall of Famer? Monster numbers. 2 Super Bowl Appearances. 1 Championship. 1 Super Bowl MVP. 2 League MVP's. Maybe another this year. Monster numbers, numerous records.

I'm a Rams fan and still love the guy. Never should have let him go, but he's only had about 5 great years, is that enough?

I think if he wins another MVP, then yes. The hall of fame be about excellence, about people who dominated the game, and Warner did. he may not have done it a super long time, but 3 MVP's is a super elite category. If he doesn't win the MVP this year, then he needs a couple more seasons like this one.

Also, he's the MVP of my fantasy team, and I love him like a brother.

I met Kurt Warner at the Clarkson 6 movie theater in Suburban St. Louis sometime around 2002. Which, sadly, has since become a PetCo. Business died down after they built a new theater in the mall. So sad, I loved going to the Clarkson 6.

True story.

Lucky bastard. Right at the end of the Rams heyday.

Also people don't forget, when Warner was benched in NY for Eli Manning, they were 5-3 in 1st place, and ended up missing the playoffs.

And I didnt just say, "Hey Kurt, big fan!", as he walked by and forced a smile. He actually stopped and talked to me and my friend. Partly because Kurt is a hell of a nice guy, and partly because my friend is the son of the Equipment Manager of the Rams, and Kurt recognized him. Brenda was with him and her hair is as scary in person as it used to be on TV.

he was my MVP in his breakout year. I had Peyton and managed to pick Warner up after the season started. I think they were the #1 and 2 QBs early in the season. The trade was a good part of my championship which was part of a back-to-back-to-back reign /bragaboutsomethingthathappenedtoolongagotobragabout


it's kinda a Eric Lindros type situation for Warner except Warner has a couple championships. I think Lindros should get in and Warner deserves it too.

Hell yes he is.


When he was good... he was the BEST.

They gave a sick stat during the MNF broadcast. It was something like 42% of Kurt Warner's career starts he has thrown for at least 300 yards. If that isn't excellence and/or domination, I don't know what is.

I came to post that stat. The sickest part is that Dan Fouts is number two on that list, at... 28%...WTF?!?!?!


Just think what that stat would be if he'd never played for the Giants? OMG I love Kurt Warner.

It's 45%. The next closest guy is Dan Fouts at 28%. What a joke. Not you, the stat.

I think he's a first ballot HOF'r right now. The only thing he has working against him, is that he is a Christian. But according to his book, He and Brenda screwed like bunnies before they were married, so maybe it offsets.



He's already in super elite category. Thank goodness fumbles don't count against passer rating.




She looks a TON better now. Have you seen a current photo?





It was 45% for Warner, 28% for 2nd place. (Dan Fouts)

Oh yes, the poor oppressed christian minority, being left out of so many things What's working against him is that he did nothing for like a block of 5 years, which should have been his prime.

His type of 'Christian' is the minority, but that's not the point. I agree about the nickel.

In Sportscenter after the game... Steve Young, "Kurt is easily one of the most accurate passers to ever play this game." Stuart Scott, "That was Steve Young that just said that boys and girls."

It's always fun to watch Kurt play. He has some sick record against the 49ers.

I heard that when he was in college he was into all kinds of drugs and whatnot, which eventually led to his born again christian thing.

I think you heard wrong about that. His Christian thing came from 1996 when Brenda's parents were both killed by a tornado.

Obv the cover story.

I will be the stick in the mud. He needs another couple good years before he is a sure fire hall of famer. And three more before he is first ballot. He had too many bad years sandwiched between 3-4 great ones. His resume right now is a lot like terrell davis. Who is not a lock though I feel he should get in (and I feel Warner should too if he has another couple good years).

The 3 plus years struggling with fumblitis will hurt him but he still may just be first ballot. Unreal stats. If the Cards don't give him at least another 2 year deal they are doing themselves a disservice.

I agree. I read this yesterday, and was trying to come up with an analogy, but this one works.

God damnit.

I think he'd make the HOF if his career ended today.

He has had 4 1/2 good seasons out of 11. I don't think that is Hall worthy right now.

You have only yourself to blame you talentless ****.

QFT



QFT



LOL

He has the 2nd highest career passer rating of all-time right now. Ahead of Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, and Joe Montana (and everyone else except Steve Young).

I knew he was good...didn't realize he was that good.

I'll fight you, I really will. I love this man like a brother. He has a sweet and beautiful wife, lovely children.. he's a golden child, and he shouldn't even need to wait 5 years to get to the hall ,he needs to go now....















(And if tom Brady had been your first pick, and you assumed your FF season was over, until Kurt Warner descended from the heavens to save you, you'd feel the same way)

I remember that season. I had Kurt Warner, Marshall Faulk, Isaac Bruce, and Torry Holt on my fantasy team. When Warner threw a TD to any one of them it counted twice...once for the QB and once for the WR. I only lost one game that season (Rams bye week).

Aside from that, if he wins the MVP then yes he's a HoF'er.

holy crap lol are you a St Louis fan, or did it just happen that way? That team was extraordinary.

I did not realize that.




Probably.



I still think the Terrell Davis correlation works. Except for one year, he has never been the Best out there, and many years he was simply awful. You also have to take into consideration his fumbles. One of his first games with the Giants he had 6 fumbles. That is inexcusable. Only so much can be blamed on small hands. I watched that game, yes the line sucked, but he was making terrible plays too.

Do I think he gets in, yes. First ballot, no way.

absolutely...at least until Georgia's kids move the team away again

I live in southern Illinois not to far from St. Louis. Rams, Cardinals, Blues...I support them all.

In

The man had an injured thumb.. he's not immortal.

In two of my leagues I took Brady with a top 3 pick and everyone laughed at me. (The laugh got louder after 8 minutes) In every league I took Warner in like the 12th round as a backup... so I'm with you.





$50?

21st and final round, 3 days before he was named the starter over lienhart. It saddens me that I oculdn't have made some killer trade for a dependable running back ( which I could really use). I would have traded brady instead of KW, 'cause I think I would have gotten more for the name. But, I'm still glad my season isn't ruined. Depending on what the scoring of your league is ( like 6 points for qb td's or something) you could make the case for brady number 1.

My league that I have Warner counts completions. I needed 61 going into Mondays game with Warner,Arizonas defense and Gore still to play. Warner got 56 himself. I didn't even draft him, I picked him up a few days after our draft. My original QB's were Romo and Cutler, I traded Romo away for Brandon Marshall after Warners first or second start. Needless to say I dodged the Romo bullet by sheer luck and my team is putting up crazy points, given my RB's are Gore, Portis and Michael Turner, who I was laughed at for drafting.

what the hell happened with you in dynasty 2 this week?

Ever tried to grip a football with a broken thumb?

You want to make a $50 bet for 8 years from now? Is that in todays dollars or future dollars? Should we calculate the NPV?




I did not realize he was hurt.

I made a $100 bet a few months ago with a Browns fan who said that Brady Quinn would be a HoFer.

What if he becomes the burth blyevin of QB's, where he's not in, but you're never sure if he's gonna stay out? You should make the bet First ballot, just so it has some closure.

Tell him to ship it

You know you can't ever win that bet.

Its not like he bet a stranger he could make 97/100 free throws or something.

You really don't think I can do it, do you?

A little while ago I was messing around from half-court and made 21-50, including 7 in a row. Does that do anything for you?

Besides make me really horny? Not much.

I still don't deny that you can make 97/100 but I would also be willing to wager on it.

I said at any given time I will make 90. I will probably need a few tries to make 97. I'm down to bet, but I think we've been here before with no way to verify anything.

No way I bet on 90. You could prob do that in your sleep.

It's prob a bet that will never happen, but we'll bring it up every 6 months or so, like it will.

FWIW I am watching my Kings beat the Clips right now wishing they would lose.

Where do you live, Sacramento? Just in case I randomly happen to be in your area with a spare hour.

Why, they could sneak into the 8th spot. You wouldn't have your team make the playoffs even if they get swept by the Lakers, than get a higher draft pick?