Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Tommorow, It Arrives...
FCP Poker Forum > Off Topic Forums > Sports- Baseball
AmScray


48 Bowman Musial RC - probably in the PSA 5/6 range. Will send it off immed to SGC for grading.
Cannot wait- totally stoked. This was my 'dream card' as a kid. Only a few more Musials to go before I'm complete.

Taking every ounce of self control I can muster to not buy this since it's such a screaming deal, but I'm a centering nit and it would annoy me forever. I'll wind up paying twice to three times that for one in that exact same condition only with good centering, so I don't know if that makes me wise for holding out for a better example, or an idiot for not loosening up my standards a bit to take advantage of a fantastic deal. .
MDXS
QUOTE (AmScray @ Thursday, October 16th, 2008, 3:50 PM) *


48 Bowman Musial RC - probably in the PSA 5/6 range. Will send it off immed to SGC for grading.
Cannot wait- totally stoked. This was my 'dream card' as a kid. Only a few more Musials to go before I'm complete.

Taking every ounce of self control I can muster to not buy this since it's such a screaming deal, but I'm a centering nit and it would annoy me forever. I'll wind up paying twice to three times hat for one in that exact same condition only with good centering, so I don't know if that makes me wise for holding out for a better example, or an idiot for not loosening up my standards a bit to take advantage of a fantastic deal. .


Very nice. My best Musial is a '59, but perhaps I'll pick a nicer one up at the big November show I go to every year.

My take is that if it's going to bother you, you should pass on this one. Other deals will come up. Why get something that will rub you the wrong way?
AmScray
QUOTE (MDXS @ Thursday, October 16th, 2008, 6:24 PM) *
Very nice. My best Musial is a '59, but perhaps I'll pick a nicer one up at the big November show I go to every year.

My take is that if it's going to bother you, you should pass on this one. Other deals will come up. Why get something that will rub you the wrong way?


59 Topps Musial is a great, great card. His first topps card ftw.
Yeah, I know I can't buy it, even though that is a GREAT deal for someone who isn't a huge centering nit.. IMO even with the centering, that card is higher than a 3. More like a 4- if it were centered right, it would probably make 5/6.
It would just drive me batshit crazy and I'd eventually have to get a centered one. I can deal with a soft corner or two, but I cannot tolerate creases, stains/writing or drastic off centering. $200 is a bit too much to pay for a filler, but that is an awfully nice filler.
BigDMcGee
I think your aversion to off centered cards reeks of OCD, for the record.
thehidden
QUOTE (MDXS @ Thursday, October 16th, 2008, 6:24 PM) *
Very nice. My best Musial is a '59, but perhaps I'll pick a nicer one up at the big November show I go to every year.

My take is that if it's going to bother you, you should pass on this one. Other deals will come up. Why get something that will rub you the wrong way?



in Toronto?
MDXS
QUOTE (thehidden @ Sunday, October 19th, 2008, 7:54 AM) *
in Toronto?


Nah, Boston area.
AmScray
It arrived- it's so nice that I'm scared shitless it's a really well executed fake.
Thankfully, the seller is a reputable dealer and he and I agreed that the card must pass SGC as being authentic and unaltered (although no guarantees on grade) or I get my money back.

I can say this- if this card is what I think it is, I just made a helluvascore. This card should get a 6, I paid for a 4.
HollywoodAFD
People still collect cards? I've got a few.... actually a lot. Full sets of 88, 89 and 90 Donruss..... unopened.

Lots of others.... I should give these away.
AmScray
QUOTE (HollywoodAFD @ Monday, November 3rd, 2008, 12:33 PM) *
People still collect cards? I've got a few.... actually a lot. Full sets of 88, 89 and 90 Donruss..... unopened.

Lots of others.... I should give these away.


In those years- yes. Use them for kindling They were so ridiculously overprinted that they have virtually no value whatsoever. I mean, a few bucks per unopened wax box...
AmScray
It's entered the pending phases with SGC... God ONE TIME give me a good grade...
HollywoodAFD
QUOTE (AmScray @ Thursday, November 6th, 2008, 10:11 PM) *
In those years- yes. Use them for kindling They were so ridiculously overprinted that they have virtually no value whatsoever. I mean, a few bucks per unopened wax box...

Yea...my timing was off. They flooded the market those years.
AmScray
Well, not a huge ZOMGHOORAY but definitely not a let down, either. It's dead-on what I had 'hoped' when I bought it.

SGC 60 (EX 5)

They shipped it to Chicago and I'm still in Florida, but I'll be home next week and I'll post pics then.
DrawingDeadInDM
QUOTE (AmScray @ Thursday, November 6th, 2008, 9:11 PM) *
In those years- yes. Use them for kindling They were so ridiculously overprinted that they have virtually no value whatsoever. I mean, a few bucks per unopened wax box...


I have 10 packs of unopened Topps 1984..I think I paid 20 dollars for 'em about 5 years ago.. should I just hold onto 'em and stow 'em away to be found in 25 years when they might be worth something?

'84 wasn't really a huge year for anyone and like you said, they were 10 of about 1.3 billion packs that were put out that year. I can tell because of the somewhat clear packaging that one is a Reggie Jackson, but that couldn't be worth more than a dollar or two, really..

Your thoughts?
AmScray
84 is really on the cusp of 'mass production'. That's right about when the sports card mania really hit its stride.
People were collecting baseball cards for 'collectibles sake' by that time, Beckett was first published that year, dedicated baseball card shops starting springing up; Topps didn't totally let the presses fly in 84 like they did from 86-92, but they were still produced en masse. There aren't any real big cards from that year; other than Don Mattingly RC which isn't that expensive.

Being unopened packs, you obviously stand a chance of pulling a gem mint card- that's a good thing. I'd say just forget about them.
thehidden
QUOTE (DrawingDeadInDM @ Friday, November 21st, 2008, 8:52 PM) *
I have 10 packs of unopened Topps 1984..I think I paid 20 dollars for 'em about 5 years ago.. should I just hold onto 'em and stow 'em away to be found in 25 years when they might be worth something?

'84 wasn't really a huge year for anyone and like you said, they were 10 of about 1.3 billion packs that were put out that year. I can tell because of the somewhat clear packaging that one is a Reggie Jackson, but that couldn't be worth more than a dollar or two, really..

Your thoughts?


84 Was Gwynn's rookie year I believe...I can't remember who else would be in there. but i like Scrams advice below.
MDXS
QUOTE (thehidden @ Monday, November 24th, 2008, 12:07 PM) *
84 Was Gwynn's rookie year I believe...I can't remember who else would be in there. but i like Scrams advice below.


Gywnn, along with Sandberg and Boggs were '83. Very easy to mix '83 and '84 Topps up though - they're very similar. The only other rookies from '84 (base sets) are Strawberry and Van Slyke (and Joe Carter for Donruss), which were a lot more exciting in 1988 than 2008.
GeneralGeeWhiz
amscray, i found my willie mccovey rookie card and my autographed rookie barry bonds ball. are those rare finds? i'm guessing yes but i don't mind a second opinion.

i'll post up pics tomorrow when i get home from work.
thehidden
QUOTE (GeneralGeeWhiz @ Tuesday, December 16th, 2008, 11:32 PM) *
amscray, i found my willie mccovey rookie card and my autographed rookie barry bonds ball. are those rare finds? i'm guessing yes but i don't mind a second opinion.

i'll post up pics tomorrow when i get home from work.



Mccovey rookie is nice! bonds autographed ball not so much. I mean it has some value but the autograph market now is pretty well depressed.
GeneralGeeWhiz










AmScray
They're not "rare" but the bonds is worthwhile...
El Guapo
lol at the 88 Matt Williams Topps card. What is that worth now, $0.50?
GeneralGeeWhiz
QUOTE (AmScray @ Tuesday, December 30th, 2008, 12:26 PM) *
They're not "rare" but the bonds is worthwhile...



QUOTE (El Guapo @ Tuesday, December 30th, 2008, 12:43 PM) *
lol at the 88 Matt Williams Topps card. What is that worth now, $0.50?


yeah, i figured that they were not worth much. more sentimental value. smile.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.