BigDMcGee
Thursday, July 17th, 2008, 8:59 PM
QUOTE (Loismustdie @ Thursday, July 17th, 2008, 8:54 PM)

Umm, they already have shot themselves in the foot from the trading standpoint. He is not even a starter in there minds!! What can they expect to receive in return? This whole circus is 100% about saving face, except it's ****ing stupid. He is still possibly a top 5, maybe top 8 QB in this league and they just want him to go away or ride the bench. It's insane.
Listen, I'm not arguing from a team stand point, what they are doing is stupid. pretty much everyone agrees favre, this season, would be better than aaron rodgers.
The long term question for the packers, is, can they win the superbowl this year with favre? If they think the answer is no, then they need to see if Aaron Rogers is the man to bring them their in 3-5 years. They need to either start grooming him, or find out as soon as possible that AR is NOT that guy, and get some other quarterback. Favre just isn't the long term solution, and starting him this year could retard that long term growth.
That said, they were damn close to going to the super bowl. If that game had been like 20 degrees warmer, I bet the packers go to the super bowl. There's no reason to think that they couldn't get back ( unless they know something I don't), other than the fact that the cowboys look like a juggernaut. I think it's crazy not to take another shot with favre, and it seems to me that they are taking this whole thing illogically personal.