ajs510
Thursday, March 5th, 2009, 11:57 AM
QUOTE (Piddle Duck @ Thursday, March 5th, 2009, 2:38 PM)

So I am going to play dumb right now because thanks to the FCHL I am getting more into the prospect side of hockey that I never paid any attention to before. So on my Farm I have Colby Robak. He was drafted by the Panthers. He plays in the WHL. Is that like AA or A compared to the AHL?
You really can't get a true comparison between the AHL and the CHL (which is the parent body of the WHL, OHL and QMJHL) because the AHL is a professional league and the CHL is Major Junior. In the AHL, you have professional players ranging between 18 and 35+ years old (no ex-CHL players unless they are over 20 years old by 12/31 of the year they start playing in the AHL), in the CHL you generally have players between 16 and 20 years old, the only time the players go younger is if they are granted Exceptional Player status like Tavares was, he's been in the OHL since he was 14.
It's a fine line judging guys in Major Junior, sometimes you'll see a guy like Thomas Beauregard a couple years ago absolutely dominating the QMJHL and looking like the second coming of Crosby, then you realize that he's 20 years old and playing his 5th year in the league, that makes a big difference. Generally speaking if a 16 or 17 year old undrafted player is making a lot of noise in Junior, that should grab your attention a lot more than a guy who is 19 or 20 years old and putting up the big numbers. The guys who are still there a couple years after they're drafted aren't very likely to have a big NHL impact.
The minor league for the AHL is the ECHL, it's pro hockey but basically if you're playing there your prospects for having a big impact on the NHL are extremely slim.
Typical feeder leagues for US College would be leagues like the BCHL and USHL (USHL is American Major Junior, not as prestigious by any means), you'll also see a lot of guys from Team USA (US Under 18 Development) going on to the NCAA.
My absolute favorite part of the FCHL is scouting prospects, and I'm happy to share if you want to know anything else. I used Thomas Beauregard because he's looking like a possible exception to the overager rule, he did really well in the ECHL and Montreal is giving him a chance with Hamilton (AHL) where he's continued to do fairly well. You don't know 100% what a guy is going to do in the NHL until he's actually there doing it, prospect analysis just isn't that exact of a science.