you make a good point. maybe a smaller raise? I really think smooth calling is a mistake.
Well, thats the beauty of NL. Jacks are a biznatch to play in certain situations.
lets see, a smooth call is another 2.50 assuming MP1 doesnt re-raise.
we invested 3.00 an easy amount to get away from if over cards hit.
if all under cards hit we can lead out for pot. if MP2 comes over the top of this, our instincts should tell us that he's actually got something.
If we raise preflop, whats correct, and what isnt?
Is a min raise to 6 here stupid? we hear it often, min raises are stupid, but does that change if its the 3rd raise as 1st to act post flop?
so we raise to 6, MP1 folds, MP2 pushes, easy fold.
if MP2 calls. Now we assume jacks are good.
if we raise to 10 and we get called. there isnt a good bet we can lead out for that wont commit us to the pot.
So with that being said, If you do decide to make a raise to 10 and you get called. I would push right away as long as the board looks safe.
If you honestly think your jacks are good, (meaning you assume you're against an underpair and / or A,x)
Then I'd go ahead with the raise.
If you have no idea, sometimes a smooth call is the smart play.