59 replies to this topic

[clashcityrocker]

Picking up on what was said in the Greatest Bands thread, and to provoke discussion, my top five are:1 - The Clash - The Clash2 - Up the Bracket - The Libertines3 - Definitely Maybe - Oasis4 - London Calling - The Clash5 - Abbey Road - The Beatles

[Nitro]

I don't really have a top 5.. too many to choose from, so here's just a random five in my stereo at the moment.1. Master Of Puppets - Metallica2. Obscured By Clouds - Pink Floyd3. Seasons In The Abyss - Slayer4. High Voltage - AC/DC5. Nola - Down

[TheIceman05]

clashcityrocker said:

Picking up on what was said in the Greatest Bands thread, and to provoke discussion, my top five are:3 - Definitely Maybe - Oasis

Oasis blows. Here are my Top 5. It's not correct, so don't bother trying to dispute.(In no particular order)1) Sgt. Peppers- Beatles2) The Moon and Antartica- Modest Mouse3) Yankee Hotel Foxtrot- Wilco4) Led Zeppelin II5) Led Zeppelin I3 classics and 2 quasi-indie quasi-classics.Rock and or Roll, gentelmenIce

[clashcityrocker]

TheIceman05 said:

clashcityrocker said:

Picking up on what was said in the Greatest Bands thread, and to provoke discussion, my top five are:3 - Definitely Maybe - Oasis

Oasis blows. Here are my Top 5. It's not correct, so don't bother trying to dispute.(In no particular order)1) Sgt. Peppers- Beatles2) The Moon and Antartica- Modest Mouse3) Yankee Hotel Foxtrot- Wilco4) Led Zeppelin II5) Led Zeppelin I3 classics and 2 quasi-indie quasi-classics.Rock and or Roll, gentelmenIce

Iceman, I like you, but Oasis most definitely do not blow.

[TheIceman05]

clashcityrocker said:

Iceman, I like you, but Oasis most definitely do not blow.

Thanks. That makes a grand total of 3 entities on the planet, with my mother and dog being the other two. I have (what probably amounts to an) irrational hatred of Oasis that would probably be better expressed via interpretive dance than some reasoned argument.IcePS- I left all Radiohead albums off my list, because if I included OK Computer, I would just have to include Kid A, Amnesiac, and The Bends as well, and then I'd probably put Pablo Honey #5 just for symmetry, even though Pablo Honey blows pretty hard.

[Absolute]

in no particular orderNeutral Milk Hotel - In The Aeroplane Over the SeaRadiohead - OK ComputerThe Pixies - DoolittleDavid Bowie - LowPavement - Slanted and Enchanted

[TheIceman05]

Absolute said:

in no particular orderNeutral Milk Hotel - In The Aeroplane Over the Sea

This one comes in at #6 on my non-Radiohead list. And Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain is #8

[crowTrobot]

how's this for schizophrenic tastes:1 APC: thirteeth step 2. sarah mclachlan: fumbling towards ecstasy 3. pink floyd: momentary lapse of reason4. yngwie malmsteen's rising force: marching out5. VH 16. LZ 47. anything with rachmaninov opus 39 etude #5 on it8. loudness: thunder in the east

[TheIceman05]

crowTrobot said:

4. yngwie malmsteen's rising force: marching out :lol:

I just reacted to that with an extreme awesomeness mouth-pukeIce

[Dirtydutch]

The only thing yngwie malmsteen is good for is ridiculous Japanese video game music (yes, I own that album). It makes me sad, just looking at that fat-ass.

[KDawgCometh]

ummm, how anyone lists a pink floyd album that isn't animals shouldn't ever call themselves a pink floyd fanfloyd-animalszeppelin-IVstones- beggars banquetbeatles-revolver(though the white album is up there too)yes-fragileI have to leave off radiohead as its just too hard to pick one album

[bigkg]

1. Led Zeppelin-Led Zeppelin I2. Led Zeppelin-Led Zeppelin II3.The Who-Quadrophenia4.Neutral Milk Hotel-In the Aeroplane Over the Sea5.Pink Floyd-Animals (just for you KDawg)P.S.- I never really liked Oasis, just for the record.

[Dirtydutch]

AC/DC-Back In Black( by a hair over Highway)Aerosmith- Toys In The AtticAllman Brothers-Fillmore EastBlack Crowes-Shake Your Money MakerZeppelin-IV

[Don Giovanni]

Absolute said:

Radiohead - OK Computer

thank youflame all you want but fashion nugget by cake should be on everyones list

[poguemahone68]

Five is too difficult, I'm gonna make a top 25, in no particular order:Clash - London CallingJoy Division - Unknown PleasuresVelvet Underground - Velvet Underground & NicoStranglers - Rattus NorvegicusX - Under the Big Black SunRadiohead - OK ComputerSwans - Burning WorldTom Waits - Frank's Wild YearsRolling Stones - Sticky FingersThe Who - QuadropheniaSex Pistols - Never Mind the Bollocks, Here's the Sex PistolsMinor Threat - Minor ThreatRamones - RamonesBeatles - White AlbumPink Floyd - Wish You Were HereCure - The TopJane's Addiction - Nothing's ShockingCocteau Twins - Heaven or Las VegasBlack Sabbath - SabatogePogues - Rum, Sodomy & the LashJam - Snap!Sisters of Mercy - First & Last & AlwaysReplacements - Let It BeRed Hot Chili Peppers - Uplift Mofo Party PlanJesus & Mary Chain - Psychocandy

[Absolute]

poguemahone68 said:

Five is too difficult, I'm gonna make a top 25, in no particular order:Jesus & Mary Chain - Psychocandy

Good call on that one.They never get enough credit.

[JaysonWeber]

Call me wierd but... No Guns n Roses in here? I mean.. there Greatest Hits Album is nearly orgasmic.What about the Grease Album? My friend dug that out today and we were jammin too it in the car, a GREAT way to get some real strange looks from people... Following that was a long song haphazardly named... In-A- Gadda-Da-Vida 17 minutes of pure awesomeness right there. No Joke Guys.. If you don't appreciate that song you should die slowly.

[crowTrobot]

GnR = most overrated rock group of all time