64 replies to this topic

[Citizen Erased]

Hey, guys! Hope all's going well.
So I'm mucking around with some $5PLO8, and this comes up. Figured I'd see what you guys reckon. ftr, I'm Dudeman IV
Now, I considered sending it him back, but then I pretty much concluded that he'll learn this way and that the lesson will do him good in the long run. Also, I didn't care for his attitude before he became a beggar. Still, I thought it'd make a nice little topic here regarding the entire notion of shipping money back.
Anyways, without further delay...

PokerStars Game #18654768447: Omaha Hi/Lo Pot Limit ($0.02/$0.05) - 2008/07/07 - 17:25:45 (ET)
Table 'Pogson' 6-max Seat #6 is the button
Seat 1: cutter man 6 ($1.65 in chips)
Seat 2: texan95 ($7.43 in chips)
Seat 3: marcorleone ($1.65 in chips)
Seat 4: Dudeman IV ($9.11 in chips)
Seat 5: loluno007 ($10.01 in chips)
Seat 6: whodan ($3.95 in chips)
cutter man 6: posts small blind $0.02
texan95: posts big blind $0.05
*** HOLE CARDS ***
Dealt to Dudeman IV [Jc Ac 3d Ks]
marcorleone: folds
Dudeman IV: raises $0.10 to $0.15
loluno007: calls $0.15
whodan: calls $0.15
cutter man 6: calls $0.13
texan95: folds
*** FLOP *** [Qh Js Th]
loluno007 said, "gonna get u dude"
cutter man 6: checks
Dudeman IV: bets $0.50
loluno007: raises $0.50 to $1
loluno007 said, "3 pair"
whodan: folds
cutter man 6: folds
Dudeman IV said, "good luck with that"
Dudeman IV: raises $2 to $3
loluno007: calls $2
*** TURN *** [Qh Js Th] [6d]
Dudeman IV: bets $5.96 and is all-in
loluno007: calls $5.96
*** RIVER *** [Qh Js Th 6d] [8s]
*** SHOW DOWN ***
Dudeman IV: shows [Jc Ac 3d Ks] (HI: a straight, Ten to Ace)
loluno007: mucks hand
Dudeman IV collected $17.67 from pot
No low hand qualified
*** SUMMARY ***
Total pot $18.57 | Rake $0.90
Board [Qh Js Th 6d 8s]
Seat 1: cutter man 6 (small blind) folded on the Flop
Seat 2: texan95 (big blind) folded before Flop
Seat 3: marcorleone folded before Flop (didn't bet)
Seat 4: Dudeman IV showed [Jc Ac 3d Ks] and won ($17.67) with HI: a straight, Ten to Ace
Seat 5: loluno007 mucked [4c Ad Qc 2s]
Seat 6: whodan (button) folded on the Flop

loluno007: fck misread hand
loluno007: ngr
loluno007: fckkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
loluno007: dude can u send that back
loluno007: please
loluno007: dude
loluno007: send my money back
Dudeman IV: why would I do that after your smartass comment?
loluno007: so your not gonna send it back?
loluno007: i was kidding
loluno007: y dont u be nice
loluno007: i made a mistake
loluno007: dude r u going to send it back or what
Dudeman IV: I'll consider it over time
Dudeman IV: though I hardly think you'd do the same
loluno007: i called with nothing
loluno007: i dont have anymore money
Dudeman IV: you should have invested less then
Dudeman IV: consider it a VERY cheap lesson
Dealer: loluno007, it's your turn. You have 8 seconds to act
loluno007: karma will get u if you decide to not
oluno007: u didnt even win it fairly
Dudeman IV: despite watched My Name Is Earl continually, I'm not one to believe in karma
loluno007: are you really going to keep it, i accidently called u with NOTHING
loluno007: THATS NOT COOL AT ALL
Dudeman IV: no you didn't as you called the flop and turn
Dudeman IV: doubt you did it twice
loluno007: I HAD NOTHING AT ALL
loluno007: PLEASE SEND IT BACK I'M ASKING U NICELY

The general decision reached was that if it's someone we know, it's just good measure, but random people out there is too far really.
Anyways, thoughts?

[troyomac]

Send him a penny. He'll see the transfer in his email and get all excited, then open it up and see the size of the transfer and start crying.

[Citizen Erased]

Send him a penny. He'll see the transfer in his email and get all excited, then open it up and see the size of the transfer and start crying.

lol. I actually said this to a buddy on AOL. I was gonna get a fair few people to do it for comedy's sake

[elnino]

eff that guy man,
dont ship it back.

[Giggidy]

looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
ooooooooooooooooooool

Can't believe he even asked

[Giggidy]

Send him a penny. He'll see the transfer in his email and get all excited, then open it up and see the size of the transfer and start crying.

Haha, Gold!

Add a note - rake has been skimmed

[chgocubs99]

No.

[BeaverStyle]

If you believe in Karma, ship it back.

If you believe that people who put up money and gamble and don't know the rules of the game and can't read their hand right deserve to get a second chance w/ their money back... ship it back.

If you believe that people are responsible for what they do with their money, and that you obviously were there to take his money, regardless of outplaying him or getting lucky, then keep it.

Last time I checked, Stupidity isn't a qualification for deserving money back from a misread hand.

[Paul Brevard]

Reminds me of a Monty Python skit.

"You're a nit."
"No I'm not."
"Ok, you're not. Please give me my money back you nit."

[Merby]

Just send an email to PokerStars support appending the chat log transcript and the HH numbers. Let him get his chat banned for making racist remarks, swearing, and unwelcome solicitation of money. Who knows, after reading how much of a degenerate he is, they may just forward him a bunch of Gamblers' Anonymous pamphlets and suggest that he consider a short term self-imposed poker ban.

[vonteego3]

lol... he didn't misclick, he called with top pair and a gutshot straight draw.

[Jupiter]

Board [Qh Js Th 6d 8s]
Seat 5: loluno007 mucked [4c Ad Qc 2s]

talk about misreading.
why even consider? 3 pair? he could have 15 pairs and 12 sets, he still loses.
and he's likely lying about it, which makes it worse.

[TrueAce13]

LOL at the dude. Everyone misreads their hand at some point

[James D]

loluno007: PLEASE SEND IT BACK I'M ASKING U NICELY

Lol... where exactly did he ask you nicely? He didn't even say please.

[Merby]

Lol... where exactly did he ask you nicely? He didn't even say please.

Right here:

loluno007: ngr
loluno007: fckkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

oh wait... That's where he makes a racial slur and swears...

[Suited_Up]

If you believe in Karma, you're an idiot.

If you believe it was an accident, you're also an idiot.

The end.

FYP

[pt special]

if he would have actually called with nothing...like no pair no draw nothing, then i would consider it, but he called 2 different streets and hes a joke

obv not sending it back (and i wouldnt send it back anyway)

[terradawg]

i am amazed that you would even consider shipping back to a guy who was talking smack in chat.

[bigcoled]

talk about misreading.
why even consider? 3 pair? he could have 15 pairs and 12 sets, he still loses.
and he's likely lying about it, which makes it worse.

LOL! HA!

[Pokerkid555]

So are you shipping me my money back, or what you stupid ******~!