I see a couple flaws with your list. Tom Brady deserves to be higher on the list. Although I dont like him as a QB he is a super bowl champ. He is like Manning and can make his WRs look better then they really are. Brady is a proven winner not taking away anything from the other QBs. Also Id put Rodgers ahead of Rivers. I may be bias by saying that, but I think Rodgers leads a team better then Rivers and Rivers has yet to prove he really belongs. He has put up big numbers in the reg. season but hasnt shown much in the post season. Not that Rodgers has either, but I think with more opportunity